Minutes of the Monetary Policy Meeting of the Reserve Bank Board
Sydney - 5 November 2013
Summary by Darryl Simms:
The Board left the cash rate unchanged at 2.5 per cent and the Minutes show strong signs of further cuts in either December or February.
Glenn Stevens (Chairman and Governor), Philip Lowe (Deputy Governor), John Akehurst, Roger Corbett AO, John Edwards, Kathryn Fagg, Martin Parkinson PSM (Secretary to the Treasury), Heather Ridout AO, Catherine Tanna
Guy Debelle (Assistant Governor, Financial Markets), Christopher Kent (Assistant Governor, Economic), Jonathan Kearns (Head, Economic Analysis Department), Anthony Dickman (Secretary), Peter Stebbing (Deputy Secretary)
International Economic Conditions
Data released over the past month suggested that growth in Australia's major trading partners remained around the average of the past decade. The pace of growth in China had increased a little through the year and was consistent with the Chinese Government's target of 7½ per cent. Consumption and investment spending continued to grow strongly, with the latter contributing to strong demand for resources imports. Total social financing flows had picked up after slowing in the middle of the year. The Japanese economy continued to grow, although on the basis of recent data at a slower rate than the relatively strong pace seen in the first half of the year. The latest indicators suggested that investment in Japan had begun to pick up. In the rest of east Asia, growth had continued at around its decade-average pace, while conditions remained fairly subdued in India.
Members noted that the US economy appeared to have been growing at a moderate pace (although several data releases had been delayed by the partial shutdown of the US federal government in the first half of October). The increase in payrolls had been a bit lower over recent months than earlier in the year. In addition, while house prices had risen further, housing starts and mortgage applications for purchases had declined since earlier in the year. The government shutdown was expected to reduce growth only slightly in the December quarter. Economic activity in the euro area had continued to recover, albeit at a moderate pace. Indicators of retail spending and sentiment had improved, but remained at subdued levels.
The Board noted that the updated staff forecasts for global growth were little changed from those three months earlier. Growth in Australia's major trading partners in 2013 was expected to be slightly below its decade average of around 4 per cent, before picking up to be slightly above average in 2014.
Overall, global commodity prices had increased slightly over the past month. Iron ore prices had been supported by strong growth in Chinese steel production. Thermal coal prices had increased of late but were well below levels of recent years.
Domestic Economic Conditions
Members noted that information that became available over the past month was consistent with the Australian economy continuing to expand at a below-trend pace in the September quarter. At the same time, forward-looking indicators had generally improved.
Growth in household spending looked to have remained below average in the September quarter, consistent with softness in the labour market weighing on income growth. However, retail sales had strengthened through the September quarter and there were reports from liaison of further growth in October. Motor vehicle sales increased further in the September quarter. In addition, measures of consumer sentiment were well above long-run average levels, following sharp increases in September.
Members noted that conditions in the housing market continued to strengthen. Nationally, dwelling prices were above their late 2010 peak, with prices over the three months to October increasing significantly in Sydney. Housing turnover and loan approvals had picked up noticeably. Improved conditions in the established housing market were providing an impetus to dwelling investment, with residential building approvals increasing over the year. Approvals increased notably in September, driven by a pick-up in high-density approvals, which tend to be quite volatile from one month to the next. In discussion, members observed that developments in the established housing market and the increase in new dwelling activity seen to date were among the expected effects of the low level of interest rates.
Survey-based measures of business confidence, and some timely measures of business conditions, had increased markedly over the past two months. However, it was too early to tell whether this improvement would signal a willingness of businesses to take on new risks and thereby add to employment and investment. Indicators of current conditions in the non-mining sector remained mixed. Non-residential building approvals were above levels of a year earlier. However, members noted that office vacancy rates had risen to relatively high levels and that the decline in government employment was likely to weigh on demand for office space in some markets. While investment in the mining industry had declined, resources exports, particularly of iron ore, had been growing strongly as more projects were completed.
Labour market conditions remained soft. There had been little growth in employment since earlier in the year, although the unemployment rate had been relatively stable over recent months with the participation rate declining. At the same time, the trend in total hours worked remained quite positive and there were recent signs that a number of forward-looking indicators of employment growth were no longer declining.
CPI inflation picked up in the September quarter, to 1.0 per cent in seasonally adjusted terms, although the year-ended rate declined slightly to 2.2 per cent as the initial effect of the introduction of the carbon price in the September quarter 2012 was no longer in the year-ended rate. The various measures of underlying inflation were between ½ and ¾ per cent in the quarter, which was a touch higher than had been expected, and a little above 2¼ per cent over the year.
Prices of tradable items (excluding volatile items and tobacco) rose in the quarter. A pick-up in tradable food prices accounted for much of the increase while prices of consumer durables declined further, although at a slower pace than in recent quarters. Overall, based on historical experience, it was likely that the effect of the exchange rate depreciation earlier in the year was yet to be seen in most tradable consumer prices. Non-tradables inflation had been relatively stable in recent quarters at a rate a little below its average over the past decade.
The Board discussed staff forecasts for the domestic economy, which had been revised reflecting several influences. The exchange rate had appreciated somewhat over the past three months and the fall in mining investment was expected to be larger than previously expected. Public demand was also expected to be quite weak. Working in the other direction, there had been an improvement in housing market conditions and a pick-up in measures of business and consumer confidence. GDP growth was expected to remain below trend, at close to 2½ per cent, through the next year. Growth was then expected to pick up to above trend by the end of 2015.
The outlook for the labour market over the next two years was slightly weaker than at the time of the AugustStatement on Monetary Policy, consistent with revisions to the GDP forecast. The forecast was for employment growth to be below population growth in the near term and for the unemployment rate to continue to increase gradually for the next year or so, before beginning to decline later in the forecast period as non-resources activity picked up.
Staff forecasts for inflation were little changed, with small influences from a slightly higher-than-expected outcome for the September quarter, softer conditions in the labour market and a higher exchange rate. The subdued outlook for the labour market implied that domestically generated inflationary pressures were likely to remain contained. Despite the recent appreciation, the exchange rate had depreciated in net terms since earlier in the year, with the result that rising import prices were expected to exert an upward influence on tradables prices in coming quarters (but by less than was expected three months earlier when the exchange rate was lower still). In year-ended terms, the central forecast was for underlying inflation to remain consistent with the inflation target over the forecast period.
Members commenced their discussion of financial markets with a focus on the United States. While uncertainty about raising the debt ceiling had attracted considerable attention during October, members noted that the impact on financial markets was primarily confined to the short-term money market in the United States. Yields on short-term US government debt rose by up to 50 basis points as investors were concerned that payment on these securities would be delayed. In the event, these effects were largely reversed after Congress passed last-minute legislation to continue to fund spending and suspend the debt ceiling, but only until early in 2014.
Members observed that, in contrast, longer-term yields and equity prices in the major financial markets had been relatively unaffected. Prices in major equity markets fell modestly in the lead-up to the US debt ceiling being reached, but subsequently rallied on the markets' assessment that events had reduced the likelihood of the Federal Reserve scaling back its asset-purchase program this year. This expectation was further strengthened by weaker-than-expected US employment data for September, with the US equity market rising to a record high subsequently. Members noted that the Australian equity market had also increased, to its highest level in five years.
The changed expectations about the path of US monetary policy during October also further eased pressures in the emerging market economies, with a continued unwinding of the sharp rise in bond yields that had occurred between late May and August.
The currencies of Brazil, India and other emerging economies had appreciated from their recent low points, while foreign exchange markets generally were more subdued through October. Volatility in foreign exchange markets declined further over the course of the month, despite the uncertainty over the US fiscal position. As expectations of the timing of asset purchase ‘tapering’ by the Federal Reserve were gradually pushed back, the US dollar tended to depreciate against other major currencies and on a trade-weighted basis, although this move was largely reversed later in October. The Australian dollar was little changed in trade-weighted terms over the month. Members noted that the exchange rate was around 5 per cent higher than its trough in early August and 10 per cent below its peak in April.
Members devoted time to review data on capital flows to and from Australia. They noted that net capital flows into Australia over the past couple of decades – which were the counterpart to the current account deficits – had mostly been inflows into private sector assets, but the composition of these flows had changed quite substantially over the past five years. In contrast to past patterns, most of the private capital flows into Australia since the onset of the global financial crisis had been to the non-financial sector, rather than the financial sector (mainly banks), with much of that representing inflows into the resources sector, which had funded the recent high level of investment in that sector.
Members were briefed on the most recent ABS survey of foreign currency hedging practices by Australian entities, which was released in late October, and noted that the results were similar to those reported in previous surveys. In particular, Australian entities continued to have more foreign liabilities than assets but most of these liabilities were denominated in Australian dollars and much of the remainder was hedged, which meant that Australian entities as a whole had a positive net foreign currency asset position. A further breakdown of sectoral foreign currency exposures indicated that, after hedging, Australian banks had minimal unhedged foreign currency positions.
Bond issuance by Australian banks totalled $4 billion in October but, after accounting for maturing bonds and buybacks of government-guaranteed bonds, net bank bond issuance had actually been negative in the month, which continued the decline in the stock of bonds that had commenced in March this year. This outcome reflected both the restructuring of bank balance sheets in favour of deposit funding as well as only moderate demand for credit. On the other hand, Australian non-financial corporations had recorded solid issuance of corporate debt in 2013 and there had also been higher issuance of residential mortgage-backed securities.
Members concluded their discussion of financial markets with the observation that market interest rates currently implied that no change was expected in monetary policy at this meeting.
Considerations for Monetary Policy
Recent data had been consistent with growth of Australia's major trading partners remaining around its long-term average. Growth was expected to pick up to be slightly above average in 2014. Global financial conditions remained very accommodative and volatility in financial markets had abated.
Recent indicators suggested that the Australian economy had been expanding at a below-trend pace. The revised staff forecasts suggested that growth in the near term would be constrained by the decline in mining investment, the high level of the exchange rate and weak public demand. A range of indicators showed that dwelling investment was picking up and this was likely to continue. In time, non-resources business investment was also expected to increase given the low level of interest rates and recent substantial increases in measures of business confidence and conditions. Members noted that while the timing of investment upturns was very difficult to predict, it appeared likely that growth of the economy over the coming year would be below trend but that growth could reasonably be expected to pick up thereafter.
At recent meetings, the Board had judged that it was appropriate to leave the cash rate unchanged while continuing to gauge the effects, including in the housing market, of the substantial degree of monetary policy stimulus that had been put in place over the past two years. There was mounting evidence that monetary policy was supporting activity in interest-sensitive sectors and asset values, and given the lags with which monetary policy operates, the stimulatory effects would likely continue coming through for some time. At the same time, inflation remained within the target and the Australian dollar, while below its level earlier in the year, remained uncomfortably high. Members noted that a lower level of the exchange rate would likely be needed to achieve balanced growth in the economy.
The Board's judgement was that, given the substantial degree of policy stimulus that had been imparted, it was prudent to hold the cash rate steady while continuing to gauge the effects, but not to close off the possibility of reducing it further should that be appropriate to support sustainable growth in economic activity, consistent with the inflation target. The Board would continue to examine the data over the months ahead to assess whether monetary policy remained appropriate.
The Board decided to leave the cash rate unchanged at 2.5 per cent.